5 Best Pizza Places on Long Beach Island, NJ: An LBI Vacationer’s Guide
After a long day on the beach, sometimes there’s only one answer to the question, “What should we do for dinner?”
Pizza.
Luckily, Long Beach Island has plenty of great options, whether you’re staying on the north end of LBI, right in the middle of the island or closer to Beach Haven.
If you’re searching for the best pizza on Long Beach Island, NJ, here are five LBI pizza spots to put on your vacation list.
1. Ray’s Sunset Pizza — Harvey Cedars
If you’re staying on the north end of Long Beach Island, Ray’s Sunset Pizza in Harvey Cedars is a great place to start.
Located right on Long Beach Boulevard, Ray’s has the relaxed, casual feel you want from an LBI pizza shop. Grab some slices for lunch or bring a pie back to the beach house after a full day in the sun.
It’s an especially convenient pizza option for vacationers staying in Harvey Cedars, Loveladies and the north end of LBI.
Address: 7806 Long Beach Blvd., Harvey Cedars, NJ 08008
2. BLVD Pizza — Surf City
Heading a little farther south brings us to BLVD Pizza in Surf City, another spot that gets plenty of attention from LBI pizza fans.
BLVD offers traditional round pizzas along with square and specialty pies. Their Grandma-style pizzas are particularly popular, making this a fun choice if your family likes trying something beyond a basic cheese pie.
Surf City is also right in the heart of the island, making BLVD a convenient stop for many LBI vacationers.
Address: 1503 Long Beach Blvd., Surf City, NJ 08008
3. Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant — Ship Bottom
Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant in Ship Bottom is a longtime casual LBI pizza spot and a particularly convenient choice if you're staying near the Causeway.
In addition to pizza, the menu includes plenty of familiar vacation-night favorites such as cheesesteaks, burgers, salads and pasta. That makes Speakeasy an easy option when everyone in the family isn't necessarily in the mood for the same thing.
It’s family-managed and has been an LBI favorite for many returning vacationers.
Address: 1318 Long Beach Blvd., Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
Website: https://speakeasypizzeria.com/
4. Flour Child LBI — Long Beach Township
For another style of pizza, check out Flour Child LBI, located at 8201 Long Beach Boulevard in Long Beach Township.
This newer LBI pizza spot has quickly developed a following for its pizzas, including crispy Grandma-style squares, along with favorites like garlic knots and wings.
If you're vacationing in Brant Beach, Beach Haven Crest, Brighton Beach or the surrounding Long Beach Township neighborhoods, this is an especially convenient option for a pizza night at the shore.
Address: 8201 Long Beach Blvd., Long Beach Township, NJ 08008
5. Queen City Crust — Beach Haven Gardens
Our final stop takes us toward the south end of LBI for something a little different.
Queen City Crust in Beach Haven Gardens specializes in Detroit-style pizza — rectangular pan-baked pies with a thicker, light crust and those crispy cheese edges that Detroit-style pizza is known for.
It's a great choice if you want to change things up from traditional Jersey Shore pizza during your vacation.
Address: 13504 Long Beach Blvd., Beach Haven Gardens, NJ 08008
Website: https://www.queencitycrust.com/
Pizza Night Is Better When You Don’t Have to Make the Beds!
One of the best things about an LBI vacation is keeping things simple.
Pick up a pizza, head back to the beach house and enjoy the evening — and let Pack Lite take care of some of the other vacation chores.
Pack Lite provides linen and towel rentals throughout Long Beach Island, including Barnegat Light, Harvey Cedars, Surf City, Ship Bottom, Long Beach Township and Beach Haven.
We offer:
- Professionally laundered sheets and linens
- Bath towels
- Cribs and baby equipment
- Beach equipment
- Convenient bed-making service
- Free delivery and pickup
Add our bed-making service, and instead of arriving at your LBI rental and immediately making a house full of beds, you can start your vacation right away.
Save 10% on Your August LBI Rental
There’s still plenty of summer left on Long Beach Island!
Use promo code Pack10 for 10% off your Pack Lite rental through the end of August.
Order your LBI linens, towels, baby equipment and vacation essentials at:
Whether you're grabbing pizza in Harvey Cedars, Surf City, Ship Bottom or farther south, we hope you enjoy every last bite — and every last beach day — of summer on LBI!